top of page

The Emergency Department Is Full. The Problem May Be Upstairs.

Writer: R.E. Hengsterman
R.E. Hengsterman
3 days ago
5 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

Patients waiting on stretchers in a hospital hallway, illustrating emergency department crowding and patient boarding.

Emergency department crowding has become so common that healthcare has normalized it.


Patients wait in hallways. Admitted patients stay in emergency department beds for many hours because no inpatient beds are available. Ambulances keep coming.


The waiting area is full.


Nurses move from one crisis to the next as hospital leadership looks for an alternative process, an additional dashboard, an additional throughput project, or another way to get more out of this system's remaining capacity.


Maybe we should be looking elsewhere.

A 2026 article by Kowalski et al. (Journal of Emergency Nursing) studied whether hospital nursing staff levels were related to boarding time within the emergency department. Their results warrant our consideration since they did not just examine ED nursing staff levels.


They looked upstream.


Boarding Is Not Just an Emergency Department Problem


Emergency department boarding occurs when a physician admits a patient to the hospital, but the patient remains in the emergency department while waiting for an inpatient bed.

At that point, the emergency department has completed much of its original mission. The patient has undergone evaluation, the clinical team has determined that hospitalization is necessary, and an admission decision has been made.


That is where The Deadly Wait begins.

The hospital may lack sufficient clinical space to admit. Nurses are at the heart of this clinical capability. Muirs et al. examined 335 hospitals in Florida, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania. This study used nurse staffing data provided by 1367 medical-surgical nurses and categorized hospitals based on their inpatient patient-to-nurse ratio. The better-staffed group included hospitals with a patient-to-nurse ratio of less than five-to-one, while the worst-staffed group included hospitals with a patient-to-nurse ratio of five-to-one or greater.


There was a significant statistical difference in the length of time ED patients waited to be admitted (boarding) between the two hospital groups. Mean boarding time for ED patients in the higher-ratio-staffed hospitals was 128 minutes versus 108 minutes for ED patients in well-staffed hospitals. Twenty minutes does not seem to be a significant number. However, anyone who has worked in a busy ED knows it is much more than just a time metric.


Twenty Minutes Multiplied Across a Hospital


A twenty-minute delay does not happen in a vacuum.

Consider what happens when this same twenty-minute delay occurs across the breadth of healthcare.


Add in the ambulances, the patients waiting, and the hospital beds that discharged inpatients should occupy but remain unoccupied because those discharges haven't happened.


Add in all the registered nurses who manage their assignments to meet or exceed the maximum number of patients they can care for.


Twenty minutes of "operational friction" creates waves of downstream consequences.

Nurses Create Capacity


Healthcare often frames nursing shortages as workforce issues; however, they are also capacity issues. A hospital can be operating at full licensed bed capacity (e.g., 300) but still lack the capacity to operate those beds. The reason is simple: beds need staff. Staff who assess patients. Provide medication. Monitor vital signs. Educate about post-hospital care. Plan discharges. Communicate with families and physicians. Document all care provided. Coordinate multiple aspects of the hospital.


Beds alone do not equate to functional capacity. Functional capacity exists because of personnel. As the authors point out, nurses coordinate many of the activities that dictate how patients move through a hospital, including triage, admission, transfer, and discharge.


This has implications. If nurses are assigned too many patients, each activity or process will compete with others. Time spent educating a family member on their patient's condition is time that could have been used for medication reconciliation.


Time spent communicating with a physician is time that could have been spent preparing for an admission. Although individual delays may appear minor, each can impact the functioning of an entire hospital.


This Study Did Not Prove That Staffing Causes Boarding


There is an important difference.

This was a cross-sectional study. The cross-sectional study found an association between nurse staffing levels and time spent boarding in emergency departments. However, the study cannot conclude that increased nurse staffing alone will decrease the amount of time patients spend waiting to be admitted from the Emergency Department.

 The researchers noted potential limitations.


Both the staffing and boarding data were collected in 2015 and 2016. Therefore, the results do not reflect the current (post-COVID) state of the nursing workforce.

Also, there is another challenge.


By closing down beds at a hospital due to a lack of nurses to staff them, the hospital may appear to have lowered the patient-to-nurse ratio. While closing down beds would result in safer assignments for the nurses, it limits the number of additional patients the hospital could admit.


A better ratio does not equate to greater hospital capacity.

Many variables, including physician availability, environmental services, transportation services, imaging services, laboratory services, case management services, and bed management services, affect flow through a hospital.


At least these are potential limitations. The authors used a variety of control variables for hospital-related variables, as well as methods designed to account for possible confounders when developing statistical models. Some (unidentified) confounders may remain unaccounted for.


The above limitations matter. They do not mean the results were meaningless. They permit an adjustment or refinement of the conclusions.


We found that hospitals that employ larger numbers of inpatient nurses had, on average, shorter emergency department patient lengths of stay than those that did not. We must collect current data to understand how strong the relationship is between nurse staffing and other determinants of hospital crowding.


Stop Treating Nursing as an Expense Line

  • Bed closures.

  • Boarded ED patients.

  • Increased overtime.

  • Use of contract labor.

  • Patients being discharged before completing the treatment plan.

  • Burnout from staff.

  • Increase in turnover.

  • Crowded departments do not recognize departmental budget constraints.


You would be surprised at how a staffing decision made on a Med-Surg unit can impact the nurse in charge of an ED waiting room with multiple patients who have no place to go. Healthcare leaders should realize this.


The Emergency Department Is the Symptom


Emergency departments expose the health of the healthcare system because they can't close the front door.


The waiting room shows it first, then the hallway. Then the staff.


We often ask emergency departments to solve crowding through faster triage, vertical care, discharge lounges, bed meetings, hallway beds, rapid medical evaluations, and more sophisticated patient flow systems.


A few of those interventions help. None can create in-patient nursing capacity.

The study by Muir & colleagues adds an important piece to the conversation. There were twenty minutes less emergency department boarding with better in-patient nurse staffing.

This does not confirm that the way to fix this would be to increase staff. What it shows is so much more significant than that.


Patient boarding in emergency departments does not begin within the emergency department. Patients waiting in the waiting room are waiting because the entire system is compromised.


Reference

Muir, K. J., Lasater, K. B., Sliwinski, K., Sun, B. C., Janke, A. T., McHugh, M. D., Aiken, L. H., & Golinelli, D. (2026). Shorter emergency department boarding times in hospitals with better nurse staffing. Journal of Emergency Nursing, 52(6), 1531–1538. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jen.2026.06.011


Author: R.E. Hengsterman, MSN, MA, M.E., RN

Registered nurse, night-shift administrator, and author of The Shift Worker’s Paradox and The Deadly Wait

For educational purposes only. Not medical advice.


Editorial Standards

This article follows NurseWhoWrites editorial guidelines emphasizing evidence-based practice, transparent sourcing, and real-world clinical experience.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page